- The modification of the second verse to effect a smoother transition into the bridge is an unusual formal touch, though by no means unique; see "I Should Have Known Better" for another example.
- We also have those familiar slow triplets in a number of places: the second half of the verse ("and there's no time") and almost, but not quite, in the bridge. The outtakes prove that they originally planned to present the opening hook this way too, but proved to be some combination of difficult and undesirable.
Harmony
- The hard-hitting, unique sonority of the E Major 7th chord chord is one of the essential characteristics of the song and, on the surface, is the prime motivator of musical tension.- On a more subtle harmonic level, the song also projects a groping, insecure sense of tonal footing. It's clearly in E Major on the one hand, yet as we'll see below, both the verse and bridge sections have their share of frustrated V chords and fitful modulations.
Arrangement
- In many respects, this is a "typical" Beatles arrangement of the period with several of the familiar ingredients: harmonica hook, pungent two-part vocal harmonies, drum fills, and melodic bass part.- The guitar parts are sparser than usual, leaving some chords implied by melody, bassline and context, instead of being made explicit by full-voiced strumming.
- As usual, the vocal parts are more intricately worked out than first meets the eye. Paul takes the lead for most of the verse sections with John singing in harmony below him. At the end of the first and third verses, Paul suddenly drops out leaving John briefly exposed by himself on lead, and at the end of the middle variant verse, John sings lead with a vocalese backing by Paul and George. The bridge section alternates between solo John and John and Paul in unison.
- Also, don't miss out on those trill-like ornaments John sensually tacks onto the end of his phrases in the verse.
- By the way, that opening B natural bass pickup "on 'four'" sure does remind me of "Please Please Me" :-).
SECTION-BY-SECTION WALKTHROUGH
Intro
- The intro has an odd length of five measures by virtue of the unusually elongated vocal pickup phrase at the end of it:
"There,--there's a place ..."
1 2 3 4 12 3 4 1
|E7 |A |E7 |A | |
E: I IV I IV V
- The intense mood of the song is immediately established by that dissonant major seventh chord right on the first downboat, nicely enhanced by the bent note ('D.'#) in the second iteration of the harmonica phrase.
Verse
- The verse has an unusual total length of 15 measures. It's actually built out of regular sorts of four-measure phrases until near the end where the odd length is created, as in the intro, by the stretched out pickup to the next phrase:
m.1 5
|E |A |E |A ||E |c# |B |- ||
I IV I IV I vi V
"I ---- think of you..."
9 13 3 4 1 2 3 4 1
|g# |A |E7 |A f# ||c# |- |- B ||
iii IV I IV V
c#: vi iv i
- Note how the first eight measures have a classical "open" shape, ending on the V chord. Yet, the remainder of the section, instead of routinely closing it back up, proceeds to tonally meander.
- In greater detail: the home key is established in the first phrase via the relatively weak "Plagal" cadence of I-IV. The next phrase opens up widely with those two full measures on the V chord, yet this juicy dominant is left dangling unresolved as the music veers fitfully toward g# minor at the beginning of the final phrase. This excursion is itself short-lived and the verse ultimately settles down in what would appear to be a modulation to the key of the relative minor, c#. But after all this, the next verse reverts directly right back to the home key.
- I hear the entirety of measure 8 as the V chord, though if you listen carefully, Paul plays the notes G#->A->B during the slow triplet in that measure as though he were trying to do something like the "iii-IV-V" chord cliche we saw in "Please Please Me", measure 4.
- The single most compositionally clever detail in the entire song is the way that the wailing harmonica hook phrase is worked into John's backing vocal part in measures 9 - 12. Part of the magical effect in those measures is the way that Paul and John's vocal parts climax twice on a tasty *fourth* that is resolves with their respective parts moving in contrary motion:
Paul: G# -> A John: D# E-D#-> C#
- And note, finally, how the harmonica hook reappears on cue in measure 13.
Verse Variant
- The first eight measures of this section are identical to those of the first verse. The music then continues with the following straightforward four measure phrase which reiterates the earlier open ending on V:"Like I love only you ..." |A |- |B |- | IV V
- True to form and purpose, note how when we move onto the bridge, this V chord is frustrated, yet again, by another deceptive cadence to vi!
Bridge
- The bridge is an unusal 10 measures long, though basically built out of two identical repetitions of the same four measure phrase. The asymmetrical length is created (just as in the intro and first verse) by the reappearance of the by now familiar elongated vocal pickup for the next verse section:
--------------- 2X -------------
|c# |F# |E |G# ||c# |- B |
c#: i V i E:V
B: ii V IV -> ?
(modulation abandoned)
- The sometimes restless sense of tonal direction seen in the verse is further developed here to the extreme that each successive chord keeps us guessing as to where we're ultimately headed.
- Though we start off in the relative minor key of c#, the section continues at first as though a pivot modulation to the key of V (B Major) were in the offing. Even the awkward appearance of the E chord in the third measure could "work" as part of this modulation, being "heard" as the IV of the new key, but only *if* the B chord itself would follow it; try it out yourself, see how nicely it works -- c# -> F# -> E -> B.
- It is the sudden appearance of the G# Major chord which abruptly cuts off that modulation in-progress, and briskly pulls the music right back to the key of c#. Part of me is tempted to chalk this seeming inelegance up to inexperience on their parts, though I cannot escape the thought that the groping, casting-about feeling conjured by it is germane to the spirit of the song.
Outro
- The final verse is identical to the first one though one measure shorter in duration.- Directly, in the second half of measure 14, we move into an outro in which *both* the vocal and instrumental hooks are presented antiphonally in strict alternation into a fadeout ending; a vivid, concrete presentation of what I've alluded to as the underlying paradox of the song.
SOME FINAL THOUGHTS - We have here yet another of those songs in which John apparently soft and insecure emotional core would seem to musically belie his tough, or at least more self-assured lyrics. This listener, for one, would feel much better convinced by what's professed here as an unshakable belief in this special "place", if the story had been set in straightforward, simple chord progressions and even phrases; on this level, even a dire ditty like "Misery"'s got a more relaxed phatic subtext :-).
- The song is also typically and prophetically John-like for its off-center point of view. The expressed facility to escape inside of himself in order to commune with object of his love is strange enough for starters. But even more provoking is the way in which the anxiety factor of the music combined with the escapism of the lyrics suggests that, in spite of the second-person pronoun phrasing of those same lyrics, the protagonist is not so much talking *to* his love, as he is ruminating to himself at a distance from her, and in solitude.
Regards,
Alan ([email protected] *OR* uunet!huxley!awp)
---
"Leave him alone, Lennon, or I'll tell them all the truth about you." 081291#31
---
** editorial note: even though some of the articles will inevitably have a much terser form than others, I decided to title them after all as part of the same series. Hence, the reversion to the 'Notes on ...' title here, and a renumbering of the last two ("m1" and "psily") to be part of the regular series. **
Copyright (c) 1991 by Alan W. Pollack
All Rights Reserved
This article may be reproduced, retransmitted, redistributed and
otherwise propagated at will, provided that this notice remains
intact and in place.
Click here to return.
Click here to return to AWP's index.
